Author sees hope amid the sad stories of child welfare in Canada
By Daniel Drolet
Veronica Strong-Boag, whose work Fostering Nation? offers the first-ever comprehensive look at the history of Canada’s care of marginalized youngsters, says she was relieved to find signs of hope amid much sadness.
“When I started this work, it was depressing,” says Strong-Boag, explaining that as her research progressed, she encountered story after story of children being abused and families destroyed through encounters with the child welfare system.
“It was a relief to me – and somewhat of a surprise – that I was able to finish on a hopeful note,” says the winner of this year’s Canadian Federation for the Humanities and Social Sciences Canada Prize for Social Sciences for an English-language scholarly work.
From residential schools and Barnardo children to orphanages and foster parenting, Canada has long struggled with providing care for children who for whatever reason are not, or cannot, be raised by the families into which they are born.
Boys in particular have had a tough time, says Strong-Boag, because they are less wanted in foster care than girls, and far more likely to encounter harsh discipline.
She says the good-news stories of successful adoptions are better known and understood than the stories of the children who go in and out of state care. Yet she argues that understanding the failures can teach us about the things that land families and children in difficulty.
“It’s hard to avoid the conclusion that families are routinely romanticized,” she says, adding that the idea that “love conquers all” ignores fundamental issues like poverty, the place of women in society and the lack of support for what she calls ‘caring labour’ – the work of caring physically and emotionally for people.
She says there’s a belief that if people did not love their children, it is an individual problem, not a social one. She argues that many problems with child welfare stem instead from the lack of value attributed to caring labour – work done largely by women.
Yet Strong-Boag says that as she chronicled the problems, she also started to see hopeful signs.
She says, for example, that native families and communities are making efforts to remake child welfare for native children under their own auspices.
She also says there’s an ongoing, sustained and under-reported tradition of community development – the same kind of community-building that’s associated with international development – happening among marginalized groups.
Thirdly, she says ‘graduates’ of the welfare system are starting to get together and voice their experience.
And finally, she says there’s a growing appreciation of the importance of caring labour.
That, she says, is critical. Because caring labour is set to take on a new dimension as society ages and more elderly people need personal care.
Strong-Boag hopes her work will inform the democratic debate about welfare issues such as these.
Veronica Strong-Boag is a professor of Women’s and Gender Studies and of Educational Studies at the University of British Columbia. Fostering Nation? Canada Confronts Its History of Childhood Disadvantage is published by Wilfrid Laurier University Press.